John Tucker Must Die (2006)

John Tucker (Jesse Metcalfe) has it all. He’s dating Carrie (Arielle Kebbe), Heather (Ashanti) and Beth (Sophia Bush) without the others knowledge. When the three find out that they are part of a foursome, rather than taking it out on John, they go after one another during a volleyball game as they lash out with a tossed ball to the head, a shoving match and a swat with a bag of balls. All too soon they figure out who should be really punished.

Notwithstanding the lunacy of punishing themselves rather than the titular perpetrator, the best part of the movie is the classy comedic elegance of Jenny McCarthy in the role of Lori Spencer.

Director:  Betty Thomas Writer:  Jeff Lowell Cast:
Jesse Metcalfe -  John Tucker Brittany Snow -  Kate Spencer Ashanti -  Heather Sophia Bush -  Beth Arielle Kebbel -  Carrie Schaefer Penn Badgley -  Scott Tucker Jenny McCarthy -  Lori Spencer Fatso-Fasano -  Tommy		Kevin McNulty -  Basketball Coach Patricia Drake -  Coach Williams Jeffrey Ballard -  Cute Boy Taylor Kitsch -  Justin Steve Bacic -  Skip #1 Dean Wray -  Skip #2 Jon Cuthbert -  Skip #3 Aaron Dudley -  Skip #4